1. Comment: I like the general intro layout where it gives you two options
Severity: "Good"
Heuristic: Aesthetic and minimal design
2. Comment: There's a lot of white in the front page. Even though the buttons turn green when you hover over them, keep in mind that one does not "hover over" something on mobile.
Severity: Mid
Heuristic: Aesthetic and minimal design
3. Comment: "Add genre" and "Add friends" follow one model for user input, but "Party Name" and "Party Description" follow another. Regardless of the pencil next to them, they look like a title and description for the overall page.
Severity: High
Heuristic: Consistency and standards
4. Comment: The magnifying glass in the form for Add Genre and Add Friends is slightly misleading. Usually that's a button indicating a search function, but it doesn't do much here.
Severity: High
Heuristic: Match between system and real world
5. Comment: Color scheme on create a party is weird. "Party name" is the only green text, which throws off the emphasis.
Severity: Mid
Heuristic: Aesthetic and minamal design
6. Comment: The cancel button doesn't work
Severity: High
Heuristic: User control and freedom
7. Comment: The "starting here" link for task 2 doesn't work. I guess that's not an interface thing.
Severity: Low
Heuristic: ...error?
8. Comment: Maybe use different wording for the song lookup than "Search a song"
Severity: Low
Heuristic: Recognition rather than recall
9. Comment: Maybe the final button to add said song should have more emphasis, like a whole block instead of a small plus sign
Severity: Low
Heuristic: Flexibility and efficiency of use
10. Comment: I'm not sure what upvoting or downvoting a song actually accomplishes. I'm guessing it affects the order of what comes next. Also the number is never updated when either direction is pressed.
Severity: High
Heuristic: Visibility of system status
11. Comment: Instead of making someone scroll all the way to the bottom to add a song (which they might not want to do), place it at the top
Severity: Mid
Heuristic: Flexibility and efficiency
12. Comment: There are no "back" or "leave" buttons anywhere
Severity: High
Heuristic: User control and freedom
Severity: "Good"
Heuristic: Aesthetic and minimal design
2. Comment: There's a lot of white in the front page. Even though the buttons turn green when you hover over them, keep in mind that one does not "hover over" something on mobile.
Severity: Mid
Heuristic: Aesthetic and minimal design
3. Comment: "Add genre" and "Add friends" follow one model for user input, but "Party Name" and "Party Description" follow another. Regardless of the pencil next to them, they look like a title and description for the overall page.
Severity: High
Heuristic: Consistency and standards
4. Comment: The magnifying glass in the form for Add Genre and Add Friends is slightly misleading. Usually that's a button indicating a search function, but it doesn't do much here.
Severity: High
Heuristic: Match between system and real world
5. Comment: Color scheme on create a party is weird. "Party name" is the only green text, which throws off the emphasis.
Severity: Mid
Heuristic: Aesthetic and minamal design
6. Comment: The cancel button doesn't work
Severity: High
Heuristic: User control and freedom
7. Comment: The "starting here" link for task 2 doesn't work. I guess that's not an interface thing.
Severity: Low
Heuristic: ...error?
8. Comment: Maybe use different wording for the song lookup than "Search a song"
Severity: Low
Heuristic: Recognition rather than recall
9. Comment: Maybe the final button to add said song should have more emphasis, like a whole block instead of a small plus sign
Severity: Low
Heuristic: Flexibility and efficiency of use
10. Comment: I'm not sure what upvoting or downvoting a song actually accomplishes. I'm guessing it affects the order of what comes next. Also the number is never updated when either direction is pressed.
Severity: High
Heuristic: Visibility of system status
11. Comment: Instead of making someone scroll all the way to the bottom to add a song (which they might not want to do), place it at the top
Severity: Mid
Heuristic: Flexibility and efficiency
12. Comment: There are no "back" or "leave" buttons anywhere
Severity: High
Heuristic: User control and freedom
RSS Feed
